|

News

Jurors award $35-m in damages to Clunie

By PAUL HENRY Crime/Court Desk co-ordinator henryp@jamaicaobserver.com

Thursday, March 29, 2012 | 5:38 AM



FORMER Deputy Commissioner of Police Owen Clunie was last night awarded $35 million in damages by a panel of jurors in his defamation lawsuit against his ex-boss and former police commissioner Francis Forbes.

A special jury of seven members deliberated for eight hours, from 11:00 am to minutes after seven last night, before returning a verdict in Clunie's favour in the Supreme Court.

An hour later the jurors went back to deliberating and returned at 9:00 with the $35 million for general and aggravated damages.

While Clunie was successful in his suit against his former boss and second defendant the attorney general, Clunie failed to win a verdict against third defendant CVM-TV, which got off on the defence of qualified privilege.

The case, which started on March 14, was brought by Clunie based on what he said were damaging statements made by Forbes against him in December 2002 and later on the CVM-TV programme Impact.

Clunie — who was a member of the Jamaica Constabulary Force for close to four decades before his resignation in 2004 — said the statements have destroyed his reputation, causing him to be sidelined by the force and led to him resigning out of frustration.

The defendants have argued that the statements were qualified privilege and fair comment.

Last night, the jurors held, among other things, that the statements were calculated to damage Clunie.

There was no immediate talk of an appeal last night following the jurors' decision.

Clunie was represented by attorneys Alando Terrelonge, Audrey Reynolds and Kristina Exell, instructed by the law firm Bailey, Terrelonge, Allen.

Both Forbes and the attorney general were represented by Althea Jarrett and Harrington McDermott, from the Attorney General’s Chambers. CVM was represented by attorneys Charles and Wayne Piper.

The trial was presided over by Justice Jenifer Straw.



Morris vows to preserve dignity of Senate

 

Appointment of blind Senate president raises optimism

 

Clarke offered nothing new in sectoral debate — Hutchinson

 

Happy days at Bannister Basic

 

This Day in History - May 18

 

Gayle’s RCB remain in IPL playoff contention

 

RSS soldier critical after being stabbed

 

Education ministry working to cut costs - Thwaites

 

One dead in St Catherine car crash

 

Beckham captains PSG in last home game

 

Police list ‘Mansaw’ and ‘Buck Major’ as 'persons-of-interest'

 

Ananda Alert: 15-y-o Danieke Williamson of Kingston 19 missing

 

Police seize two firearms in Kingston 11

 

Met Service fully prepared for 2013 Hurricane season

 

US warns nationals about Bahamas crime situation

 

Police fatally shoot man in Santa Cruz

 

Fraser-Pryce wins Shanghai 100m, Jeter injured

 

Weir wins Shanghai Diamond League 200m

 

TCI authorities drop gun charges against elderly American tourists

 

George Michael treated for 'minor' injuries

 

Today's Cartoon