|

Editorial

Wishing the new Government well

Saturday, December 31, 2011



Elections always provide plentiful food for thought and analysis.

In that respect, few Jamaican elections could have bettered Thursday's.

Against all reasonable expectations and in the face of opinion polls suggesting the elections would be neck and neck, the People's National Party (PNP) won by almost a two-one seat majority: 41-22 according to the preliminary results.

Such was the magnitude of the defeat for the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP), which has become the first one-term Government in the history of modern Jamaica, that — pending the result of recounts — at least two former Cabinet ministers lost their seats.

Further, less than half of the 1.6 million people who were registered bothered to vote. That's an astounding statistic that should worry not just the JLP but the PNP as well.

Obviously, the JLP will be asking itself what it was about its four-year-old administration that could have so turned off Jamaicans.

It seems clear, as JLP spokesmen have themselves conceded, that the atrocious handling of the issues surrounding the extradition of former West Kingston 'don' Mr Christopher 'Dudus' Coke hurt the party badly. Hard as they tried, the JLP, which came to power in 2007 trumpeting the promise of transparency and good governance, could not seem to shake the suggestion that not just former Prime Minister Mr Bruce Golding and a few around him, but the entire Government betrayed the public trust.

Then, as elections approached, came the fall-out from the alleged misuse of funds associated with the more than US$400 million road programme, the Jamaica Development Infrastructure Programme (JDIP). It would not have helped that even as the scandal escalated and elections approached, the surfaces of many of Jamaica's main roads were as scarred and scoured as they have ever been.

There were other issues of course. The several spats with public sector workers, including teachers and police, over salary and other issues, and allegations of arrogance and high-handedness would have hurt the Government.

The breakdown in the relationship with multi-lateral lender, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), will also have undermined confidence.

But at the bottom line, it seems to us, 'bread and butter' issues would have most hurt the JLP. For while outgoing Prime Minister Andrew Holness and other Government spokesmen spoke glowingly of their success in maintaining macro-economic stability in the face of the worst global economic recession since the 1930s, they seemed to gloss over the immediate plight of the poorest among us.

The truth is that even without resort to official statistics, poverty levels are intolerably high. This in a context in which — with all due respect to the PATH programme — there is woefully inadequate social safety provision. In the eyes of many Jamaicans, suggesting that the problems of impoverishment and unemployment will be addressed when sustainable economic growth is achieved simply wasn't good enough or immediate enough.

It is in that context that the PNP's proposal for an emergency employment programme would surely have gained resonance. We have heard from the PNP that it will seek to more creatively use funds from the Tourism Enhancement Fund and also seek to renegotiate with the Chinese in terms of the use of JDIP funds for projects that are labour intensive.

It's now left to the PNP to put more 'meat on the bones' in terms of how this job programme is to be executed in a context of demands by the international lenders for expenditure cuts and economic austerity. We wish the new Government well.



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 191228bcbe16464fbd2f1bb59357ef6c
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (18)


4/20/2012
Brukins, Let's agree to disagree ucsabee you have your firm belief and so do I People should not have fun sex with multiple partners? then produce kids from uncaring men, then want the state to be responsible for their care PERIOD. That lady at 00:54, don't her children go to public school? She should pay someone must pay for them. It can't be loans, loans more loans. Tax what that they eat ucsabee that's the only way to pull them in the taxnet.
christopher benloss
1/8/2012
Really, Joseph Edwards?! For the 4 years that the JLP has been in office Jamaica has been downgraded by various rating bodies and we are now dead last among ranked Macro Economic nations (142 out of 142). If that is managing what would you call mismanaged? If the PNP degraded the Economy in 18 years, it was a free fall to the bottom for 4 years with the JLP. Let go of your biases, it won't make us better.

1/6/2012
I found just what I was nedeed, and it was entertaining!
Joseph Edwards
1/3/2012
Simply put the PNP sold a lie the people bought it now they will have to live with it for 5 years. No matter how you try to gloss it the JLP is better at managing the country than the PNP licky licky and nammy, nammy people are our problems to include Teachers, Police and Nurses. When there is no more lenders and you guys cant get pay from borrowed funds you will understand what the JLP was doing, which you rejected. You cut off your nose to spite your face ok, the flip side awaits the country.
Robert Gray
1/2/2012
There is a saying here in the United States that goes like this, "God does not like ugly". The ads put out by G2K were very "ugly" and distasteful. The ads utterly villified Mrs.Portia Simpson Miller. They were a turn-off to myself and other well-thinking and intellectually honest Jamaicans who know the facts about the PM-designate's academic credentials. On top of that, Jamaicans are very smart voters. Many did not get the promised jobs. They also remembered Dudus,Tivoli, JDIP etc.
Peter Lawrence
1/1/2012
Heh,heh! Clovis has outdone himself today. Very good and subtle. In fact one of the best satirical criticisms I have seen from him lately. Who is the tattered, scared, seemingly mad, old man of 2011? and who is the baby of hope , standing before an EMPTY room painted in orange and red? The colours speak for themselves.

1/1/2012
Like the editor and out of concern for the people of Jamaica I wish the new government well. Portia now has her mandate and I hope the senior members of her party help her through these trying times. The task will be herculean. Both parties must take heed of the low voter turn out. The lowest since independence. The people have made a statement, hope they can recognize that or it will come back to haunt them.
Peter Lawrence
12/31/2011
contd: We got Parl. Democracy from England, but the prestige of a few "Sirs" and opp. to liase with B/palce royals now & then can't cross it now. To start, why can't we attract industrial assembly from Green Tech Jobs. Many things China produces for US market, we can do, with much less ship costs , while retaining good relations with China. We need not go for current fads for retail education / med schools from US which really send back our cash to US . PSOJ/ GOVT shold be like Ba- -y & Bench
Peter Lawrence
12/31/2011
contd: potential for econ. growth. we need to take hold of the proximity and good relations re the world leader USA. BUSINESS opps must be the main driver with SENSIBLE links to US seeking to expand. Our leaders must EDUCATE themselves in US Psychology, as Japs did. They had men at conferences even noting/ studying the JOKES americans laughed at during business confs. JEEP is a TEMPY/tho needed, sop. The richest man in Jaya is Butch , in a growth business based on USA trade. contd
Peter Lawrence
12/31/2011
This premature election MUST have been caused by a hidden crisis/crises. My pick would be two:Govt disagreement with IMF conditionalities, on top of unsavory revelations to come out of the Dudus sentencing scenario. The very peaceful nature of this election campaign , and national ,almost, camaraderie suggest the value of strongman Dudus in mobilising votes, by whatever means. Jamaica now has a chance to rid itself of gun politics from shower or comrade. Jamaica has not realised true
contd
John Smith
12/31/2011
Happy New Year to Jamaica, the PNP, Portia Simpson-Miller and a very special one to Bruce Golding, Andrew Holness, the JLP, the Observer, and last but certainly not least, Clovis! I'm sure you'll enjoy it immensely! Give thanks for the fruits of your past labours. :-)... ;-)
John Smith
12/31/2011
The PNP won the popular vote by 46,122 votes (forty six thousand one hundred and twenty two)... There were 40,000 new voters enumerated. The G2K's theory is questionable. One thing I can say is that they really did themselves in when they told all their members to put the X beside the head! Therefore every one of the new people who dem enumerate fi JLP (and who are also not very discerning) woulda put dem x beside di head!
sharp sharpiro
12/31/2011
...i dont share the same optimism as the PNP supporters dancing right now on the streets as if all of Ja's problems are now over with the change of govt..am not excited for jamaica,its a tough choice,a choice between judas(JLP) and barrabas(PNP).....there is no Jesus in sight at all...i did not sight any new faces in the PNP camp that night at their victory parade,same old faces if u ask me..so what is this excitement all about?can any one tell me?
Mark Forbes
12/31/2011
@BDeportee, I totally agree with your analysis.
@PLawrence, the PNP didn't outsmart the JLP, the JLP outsmarted themselves. They allowed the G2K too much influence over the direction of the party and the G2K is not as smart as they think they are. This member is now saying that the youthful Holness' appointment, which was hyped as political coup, couldn't even attract the youth to the JLP. I would think though, that the JLP had more of the youth support, they just didn't turn out to vote.
John Smith
12/31/2011
Editor, we see eye to eye on this one. The JLP did not communicate effectively their plans, if any, to ease the burdens faced by those below the poverty line. Despite all the derision aimed at the PNP's JEEP the JLP had no branded jobs vehicle. In that sense even the negative press helped the PNP with JEEP - the initial proposal was roundly criticized & analysed, some liking some parts & disliking others. The PNP presented something for the people to think & decide on.
PL BOGLE
12/31/2011
The JLP Government was very insensitive to the plight of poor, and it was clear that the JLP government didn't understand that governance was never allowed to become a conceptual straight-jacket but was expected to function as a rather loose framework within which each researcher could creatively explore political issues of significance, for instance macroeconomic and social policies. Hopefully a PNP government will be more creative by balancing the budget and improving people’s lives.
Peter Lawrence
12/31/2011
I am amazed by the statement by the G2K that the reason for JLP election loss is that they were "outsmarted" by the PNP. The nature of the outsmarting was attributed to "a deepening of the electoral process", namely that PNP "TRICKILY and apparently SLYLY did the low ploy of registering more voters in areas of marginal seats. Dudus/Manatt had nothing to do with it!!! This rabid nonsense deserves three or even four dinosaur tails. Samuda said it right , sit at his feet and learn politics.
British Deportee
12/31/2011
You've referenced tardiness in the Coke extradition request as the #1 reason for Thursday's result, but the huge jump in citizens' confidence which accompanied AH's ascension to PM has contracted that theory. As I see it, a large portion of the population had hopped onto Holness' bus, & many were willing to be chauffeured by him, but after travelling a mile down the road, it had become apparent that the he wasn't an experienced driver. He was unqualified & ill-prepared for the job, that's it...

Designating Mandeville a university town makes sense

  2 comments

 

A tough balancing act

  5 comments

 

Time to shift from austerity to growth strategy

  4 comments

 

Adopt the Grace Foods template

  0 comments

 

Heed Bishop Gregory's advice

  3 comments

 

Now you're talking, Mr Christie!

  7 comments

 

Gov't must use tax policy, fiscal expenditure to reduce income inequality

  0 comments

 

JPS’s first task is rebuilding trust

  0 comments

 

Complete the circle of Independence

  10 comments

 

Carib should take damaging rum subsidies to WTO

  0 comments

 

Pressure in an Olympic year

  0 comments

 

Nice move to encourage Jamaicans to vacation at home

  2 comments

 

More tax raids, yes, but more finesse too, TAJ!

  3 comments

 

What would we do without PetroCaribe?

  1 comments

 

Why Monsieur Sarkozy became a one-term president

  2 comments

 

Are these the leaders of tomorrow?

  9 comments

 

Politics of appointing and recalling our diplomats

  3 comments

 

Look what we have come to!

  3 comments

 

Bloodied, but unbowed - the splendid example of Mr Myers

  0 comments

 

Just so we don't wash our dirty linen in public

  7 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do/Would you disclose details of your salary with your spouse? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: