|

Editorial

The negative push factor in Jamaica's brain drain

Monday, November 14, 2011



JAMAICA has been experiencing 'Brain Drain' since the 1950s and a 'Brawn Drain' since the late 19th century.

The society was happy and relieved because migration was a vent for surplus labour. This release of unemployed labour has been a direct consequence of the failure of the Jamaican economy to provide employment for all of its labour force. It also stemmed from the subsistence wages which many of the employed were forced to accept.

The 'Brawn Drain' was seen as beneficial for the economy, but the 'Brain Drain' was regarded as retarding economic development by depriving the economy of scarce skills.

In the 21st century, the critical determinant of economic success is the quantity and quality of human resources. Jamaica, therefore, cannot afford to lose any of its skilled human resources, given the paltry state of the Jamaican economy. The idea to keep, train, and retain in productive activity the maximum amount of human resources must be a central plank of economic policy.

Jamaica has been training a sufficient quantity of skilled human resources but we have not been able to retain an adequate number of them.

One reason for that is the migration of people in search of employment and/or higher remuneration. This is inevitable in a world with much richer countries in need of young, skilled workers, eg the United States. But we are failing to attract Jamaicans abroad to return home, and therefore, despite remittances, their contribution is lost to Jamaica.

Ironically, the vast majority of Jamaicans abroad want to return to their homeland. But when many of them attempt to do so they are either discouraged by their fellow Jamaicans, or are faced with the hardships of living here.

However, the real negative push factor they face is the vicious animosity of their fellow Jamaicans who subject returnees to many unpleasant acts, including robbery.

The facts are not in dispute. What, though, explains this antagonistic behaviour? First is jealousy, the most pandemic of human emotions spawned by resentment that Jamaicans who lived and worked abroad come back economically better off.

There is, too, an entrenched feeling that with more Jamaicans returning home, the more people will have to share scarce resources like land. This, of course, is arrant nonsense, because returnees enlarge the economic pie with their skills, experience, and capital.

Then there is the misguided view that once a Jamaican goes abroad to live and/or work, he or she is somehow no longer a "true" Jamaican. The departure is subconsciously viewed as an act of betrayal and the sojourn in foreign lands is assumed to contaminate them. They are derided in the same vein as the "Colon man" in the old folk song.

Ironically, the overseas Jamaicans and those who return home are among the most patriotic, hard-working, and law-abiding citizens. In many cases, they give back to this country beyond measure. Proof of that is in the stories of this year's nominees for the Observer Business Leader Award.

It is not asking too much, we believe, to welcome our fellow Jamaicans back home when they decide to return.



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha a951141aac084baa8e28d9d64e552b32
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (4)

Beverley Hanson
12/4/2011
Yes, yes, the high crime rate in Jamaica is keeping me away. I don't have burglar bars on my home here(U.S.A) and I haven't been the victim of a crime in the 13yrs I've been here. I was robbed quite often in Jamaica so I'm afraid to return although I'm tired of the prejudices here and I could more readily achieve my dream of being a college professor in Jamaica. It makes me sad to know my own country is unsafe to live in.
moses reid
11/17/2011
An interesting editorial. Yes, crime is a major factor in the lives of returnees but there are probably more reasons. I was born in Jamaica and regularly visit for vacation. My major complaint, apart from crime , is a lack of pride in things Jamaican. The food, one has to fight to get resorts to do Jamaican food, and the culture, i.e stories about minor English or American clebs in the papers. Why stay in Jamaica if it is better overseas?
Jair GM
11/15/2011
@KNG+ There are already significant incentives for returning residents but the largest deterrence is crime. Until that monster is slain, many will not return. I myself remain in two minds on the subject but I have hedged my bets by retaining ownership in Jamaica and Belize as well as NY. If I was even certain that sincere resources were being inputted into the crime fight, I would pack my bags and return. However, until I see resources being committed to fight this scourge, I will stay away.
Nejeeper KNG
11/14/2011
Wonderful and frank editorial; there are J’cans “on their mark, ready, set and want to go home to JA.” They keep up with every incident in JA (crime etc) waiting for that green light. We are talking about highly intelligent and well experience J’cans. The govt should start looking into incentive for returning residents. Educators, Information Technology experts, structural engineers and criminal justice are areas that could benefit from this effort. A J’can is a J’can no matter what!!!

Designating Mandeville a university town makes sense

  2 comments

 

A tough balancing act

  5 comments

 

Time to shift from austerity to growth strategy

  4 comments

 

Adopt the Grace Foods template

  0 comments

 

Heed Bishop Gregory's advice

  3 comments

 

Now you're talking, Mr Christie!

  7 comments

 

Gov't must use tax policy, fiscal expenditure to reduce income inequality

  0 comments

 

JPS’s first task is rebuilding trust

  0 comments

 

Complete the circle of Independence

  10 comments

 

Carib should take damaging rum subsidies to WTO

  0 comments

 

Pressure in an Olympic year

  0 comments

 

Nice move to encourage Jamaicans to vacation at home

  2 comments

 

More tax raids, yes, but more finesse too, TAJ!

  3 comments

 

What would we do without PetroCaribe?

  1 comments

 

Why Monsieur Sarkozy became a one-term president

  2 comments

 

Are these the leaders of tomorrow?

  9 comments

 

Politics of appointing and recalling our diplomats

  3 comments

 

Look what we have come to!

  3 comments

 

Bloodied, but unbowed - the splendid example of Mr Myers

  0 comments

 

Just so we don't wash our dirty linen in public

  7 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do/Would you disclose details of your salary with your spouse? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: