|

Columns

China Harbour Engineering and Greg Christie’s huge error

Mark Wignall

Thursday, February 02, 2012



AS one of the most indefatigable public servants that this country has ever seen, Contractor General Greg Christie will naturally be in the front of the line when God comes in the great rapture – the “take-up” of his most favoured people.

Just what this corrupt country has always needed, zeal is his middle name. At times, however, one is forced to use the word “overzealous”.

The contractor general’s proactivity in being a “warner man” to the new government strikes the pose as the alter ego of John the Baptist; in the present instance, laying out a warning to the PNP administration to cease forthwith the contractual arrangements between China Harbour Engineering and the government of Jamaica.

He has raised “strong objections to the apparent intent of the former government to award, without international competitive tender, a sole-source contract to CHEC to, among other things, complete the construction of the Spanish Town to Ocho Rios North-South Link of Highway 2000 and the Jamaica Development Infrastructure Programme (JDIP)".

If he has his way, the US$600 million deal with China Harbour for the completion of the North-South link of Highway 2000 and the granting of a 50-year toll concession/maintenance arrangement would be immediately stopped.

Will someone, somewhere, please wake up Mr Christie to the fact that China Harbour Engineering (CHEC) is a stateowned entity, that is, under the evolving economic/political arrangements in China it is subject to the Chinese government’s rules, regulations and control. Even while he was pontificating over the China Exim Bank-funded JDIP, the present matter concerning the North-South link of Highway 2000 involves not a loan but an investment of US$600 million by CHEC! In his zeal, was Mr Christie not aware of this?

Why would an overseas investor need the contractor general to insert himself in a process where the CG has, pretty much, no business?

I have in my time been a bit of a crusader on certain matters, but so far I have resisted efforts of earning my wings as a crusading angel. To follow the contractor general’s logic one would be tempted to believe that dozens of investors and zillions of dollars of FDI are eagerly waiting, outside of Jamaica’s territorial limit, for Mr Christie to clear the hurdles.

Well, I am not aware that this is so, and while I am not suggesting that Mr Christie temper his approach with a world view of big business and the interface with small economies like ours, it would be useful if he could balance his eager/angelic side with a global view that segues to the pragmatic.

Listed are just a few of the world-renowned projects that China Harbour has been involved in.

The Malta Dry Dock – which is, 360m long, 62m wide and 12.5m deep. The Northwest Rail Depot Building

http://www.chec.bj.cn/tabid/110/Default.aspx (Hong Kong). The EMU Building is 470m long, 60.4m wide, 11.2m high of reinforced concrete structure. The Macao International Airport – constructed on an artificial reclaimed island created by CHEC.

Then there has been the Qasim International Container Terminal – Terminal 2

http://www.chec.bj.cn/tabid/130/Default.aspx – located in Qasim Port, Karachi, Pakistan. The project includes mainly filling of container yards, construction of quay and berth dredging. The 3rd Nanjing Yangtze River Bridge – a cablestayed bridge of 15.6km in length and a main span of 648m.The main pylons are “A” shape constructed from steel and concrete.

There has also been the huge Damma Oil Terminal at the Port of Sudan - a 310m long quay and a 275m connection to shore and the Macau Grand Lisboa Hotel – a 228m high, 44-floor building covering 12,000 m2 .

In the grand scheme of things, China Harbour Engineering is no fly-by-night, “grab and flee” company. The company has been granted 160 awards for its signature projects, and among these outstanding achievements CHEC is also credited for the design and construction of the two longest sea-crossing bridges in the world, namely the Hangzhou Bay Bridge (36 KM long) and the Shanghai Donghai Bridge (32.5 KM long), both in China.

The new PNP administration is well aware of the goodwill stored up between Jamaica and China and someone in the administration needs to sit down with Greg Christie, share a cup of fevergrass tea with him and implore him to get some sleep before his zeal renders him an insomniac.

In this complex world where investment funds are not as liquid as they used to be, the Chinese, motivated by their need to gain influence and a physical space in the Western Hemisphere, have decided that Latin America and the Caribbean are ripe for expansion. Ever since Jamaica adopted the “one China” policy in the late 1960s under a JLP administration, the Chinese with long memories have not forgotten. In the more modern era, a new PNP administration will be well advised to continue this relationship to the benefit of Jamaica.

For those who came in late, in the 1960s almost all small economies on the Caribbean recognised Taiwan as a sovereign state. Jamaica broke from that and adopted a stance called the “one China” policy where mainland China was seen as THE China.

The Chinese have made Jamaica the hub of their business interests for Latin America and the Caribbean. Is Mr Christie not aware of this?

Once that Spanish Town to Ocho Rios leg is up and running, the potential economic benefits are enormous. Freight moving quicker, public transport saving petrol and getting people to their destinations faster, private car owners more willing to travel and spend their recreational money in rural areas in between.

Good sense must prevail in our association with China Harbour Engineering. I expect that the new PNP administration will apply all the necessary pragmatism and recognise that in this instance, the complexities are well worth our involvement with China Harbour Engineering. If there are those with an alternative route to fixing our physical infrastructure, let them spell it out and do so loudly.

In the interim, Mr Christie has a job to do even as Jamaica cannot await the luxury of God’s coming to build us all super highways. The Chinese can build them though.

— observemark@gmail.com



POST A COMMENT


You must first register and then login to be able to post a comment.

HOUSE RULES

 

1. We welcome reader comments on the top stories of the day. Some comments may be republished on the website or in the newspaper – email addresses will not be published.

2. Please understand that comments are moderated and it is not always possible to publish all that have been submitted. We will, however, try to publish comments that are representative of all received.

3. We ask that comments are civil and free of libellous or hateful material. Also please stick to the topic under discussion.

4. Please do not write in block capitals since this makes your comment hard to read.

5. Please don't use the comments to advertise. However, our advertising department can be more than accommodating if emailed: advertising@jamaicaobserver.com.

6. If readers wish to report offensive comments, suggest a correction or share a story then please email: community@jamaicaobserver.com.

7. Lastly, read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy, and before commenting you need to register, conveniently, by clicking the link above.



Comment (required):

You have characters left.
captcha 92295a70b32d47a3b9ec5c12bd0bdf6a
Enter text seen above:

For information about privacy please read our Privacy Policy.

I have read and accepted the Terms and Conditions


COMMENTS (21)

Patricia Lu
2/4/2012
It's amazing how in one posting a few weeks before the election wonda & her blog partner were playing the peace card. Now...everyday wanda oman de pon a partisan campaign...I was happy when you elected to leave a while back. Still waiting for the exit- the nonsense is nausiating. Onu enslave to unu ideologies and will forever serve as political viruses that causes the epidemic of partisan violence and corruption in our Island nation. Plantation mentality abound.
RED ANTS
2/3/2012
@Devon T,you and your fellow labourites will tired of red ants on this poster board,the Jamaican people are quiet happy because they could not allow your party to get away with the level of corruption and destruction which was taking place that you labourites are endorsing.
Devon T
2/3/2012
@ anthony Johnson, you have send the two to BED. havet heard them since...Mama-Ess gone do research fi har comeback. Red Ants doing some burrowing...
Anthony Johnson
2/2/2012
@Wanda Woeman. You and Red Ants are the two aadvarks here. As far as I know an aadvark is a medium sized noctural mammal often called an earth pig because of it burrowing habits. You and Red Ants always have the first post on all the articles, seems like you two are always up in the middle of the night (noctural). Plus the word burrowing sounds just like borrowing. Isn't this what you and your party is about "borrowing and eat a food". Who are the REAL AADVARKS now. Check yourself first.
Noel Richards
2/2/2012
J'cans will never learn. US$600 Million for another road with a fare, to nowhere. What about power generating ability and cost? Do not believe announcements from the politicos about green energy investments. Whatever Christie's intent, at least question the efficacy and wisdom of spending money on roads that will not make JA Better. Prioritize! Time and learning the hard way is going to prove the relationship with China to be the wrong choice. China is overdue a very hard economic landing.
RANDOLPH PARKS
2/2/2012
Mark,the ability to string togather a few grammatically correct sentences does not make one a sage.Your piece is shallow and deviod of logic.You are embarrassing yourself .You need to stop,please!
Luv Quest
2/2/2012
How their lives have changed….. :) @Meat Head...good point.
Mark Phillips
2/2/2012
Mark has said the JLP would win. This did not pan out.
Luv Quest
2/2/2012
Mark the good messenger could you go out in the trenches and find out how the comrade’s lives have change since the election? They are running around acting like they are better off already and we all know better. When small-minded people squeeze themselves into certain situations it goes on show every time they pretend to be aware. All we want is value for our money; not a display of the Peacock with the main feathers. (Especially just for attention).
Mark Phillips
2/2/2012
Mark Wignall was the one who said Olint was sound and David Smith is a financial wizard. I take everything he now says skeptically.
W Morgan
2/2/2012
And Mark is the only one smart among the the 2.7 million of us!
N Manley Blythe
2/2/2012
Mark, what is the "huge error" that Mr Christie has made? 
You have shown the competence of CHEC - Terminals, Ports, Buildings, etc. 
You have Dabdoubed Mr Christie - "warner man" (childish). 
You have belittled Mr Christies intelligence and competence - "Will someone, somewhere, please wake up Mr Christie to the fact that....(CHEC) is a state-owned entity......subject to the Chinese government’s rules, regulations and control." Further, what are these, and, how do they apply?
What is the error?
Meat Head
2/2/2012
As described, this deal does appear to be outside the CG's mandate. However, it is still a valid question whether this contract with CHEC is prudent; e.g., the return reasonable for what amounts to a loan, repayable over 50 years from the tolls collected. But, even if it isn't, what business is that of the CG, assuming there is no corruption? Indeed, if prudence is part of what the CG does, why isn't he part of the IMF negotiations?
N Manley Blythe
2/2/2012
"He has raised “strong objections ...intent...to award, without international competitive tender, a sole-source contract to CHEC.."
"...if he could balance his eager/angelic side with a global view that segues to the pragmatic."
"Why would an overseas investor...where the CG has, pretty much, no business?" No business??
Mark, is Christie wrong? Or, are you asking him to turn a blind eye while being right, because we need the investment? 
Mark, is his objection legit or not? Please clarify.
Devon T
2/2/2012
I like Greg Christie's Work Ethics but he has got to be careful not to be seen as a hop scotch jumper who do all he can to stay in the corner of the one who keep watch over his contract. The guy has shed light on some dodgy stuff in JA but i have to agree with Mark, He spends so much time talking to the media ...Head over heart and in my view, Overzealous is a mild way to put it. I await the future.
Tone Bag
2/2/2012
Mark the accolades you heaped onto Mr Christie maybe well deserved which eclipses your integrity You say that God isnt going to finish the project so CHECH should be allowed to continue for expediency sake because its an inter-govt loan the benefits to be had once completed & given their accomplishments You implied that the then govt corruption cant be addressed Our doubts lays not with CHECHs acumen but with the previous govt & you My advice is leave Mr C alone & drink less of the mad pus juice
Donavon Murray
2/2/2012
While you're in the "infrastructural development" writing mode"Mark, also explore the forward and backward economical linkages with regards to Agriculture; Real Estate; Tourism and Technological transfer (to name a few).
This taxi / bus man need yu fi talk up (write up) the things :-)
Donavon Murray
2/2/2012
Mark, while I may call myself your ‘Transportation Consultant and Service Provider’, I’m really just a humble taxi / mini-bus operator and I need your help to articulate to the powers-that-be how they could renegotiate Bouygues Travaux's contract to include a revival of the railway. They could offer to extend the life of their BOOT arangement by say five to ten years and let them bouild and operate the service. That way they won't breach the contract by reviving the rail service.
Donavon Murray
2/2/2012
Ok. Now write one outlining how the “China’s hub on the USA eastern seaboard” concept would be greatly enhanced by Dr. Lloyd Cole’s massive dry-dock project in Jackson Bay, Clarendon. Explain to the good CG, the role he would need to play to prevent “Politicians and their creepy-crawly operatives” in the varied ministries from trying to use Govt. initiated foreign investments as a feeding tree.
wanda woeman
2/2/2012
@Red Ants be careful of the aardvarks. They are on the hunt and still smarting from December 29.
RED ANTS
2/2/2012
Mark,I can see you didn't have a cup of tea before you start taking your ego out on Christie but i understand your cause since you stated in one of your article sometime ago that the JLP have the Chinese money to push for a second term.Don't you think the Chinese are asking themselves what kind of corrupt government they got mix into.What is now brewing between Henry and AH doesn't that tell you something smell bad. Mark someone need to sit with you and give you some black tea.

'Compassion without Compromise': Church throws down the gauntlet

  0 comments

 

Gloria Palomino: A lifetime of voluntary service to the police

  0 comments

 

Fast fall in a slow system

  2 comments

 

Parents have ultimate responsibility for their children

  3 comments

 

IOP ball back in Omar's court

  0 comments

 

Needed: a collective voice in the G20 for developing countries

  0 comments

 

No growth without social cohesion

  0 comments

 

Let's get our priorities right

  1 comments

 

A high price to pay for physical perfection

  0 comments

 

Don't go there, Ronnie

  0 comments

 

A time to deal with the CAL/Liat conflict

  0 comments

 

Greece gets another chance to tackle its fiscal dilemma

  0 comments

 

Time for a revolution in education

  1 comments

 

Obama: President, not Pastor of America

  15 comments

 

Taxi drivers and a clean Kingston Harbour

  4 comments

 

Obama's brave but risky evolutionary trip on gay marriage

  22 comments

 

Caribbean to join social media invasion of London Olympics

  0 comments

 

In God we trust?

  12 comments

 

Jamaica's external judiciary

  10 comments

 

Spain confronting economic crisis with determination and deep structural reforms

  0 comments

 

Today's Cartoon


Poll

 Do/Would you disclose details of your salary with your spouse? 
Yes
No

View Results

Results published weekly in Sunday Finance


Username:
Password: